Had this experience on stage yesterday with my 6A NV band...

Tone
1 - Consistently
2 - Consistently
3 - Usually
4 - Consistently
5 - Usually

Technique
1 - Consistently
2 - Consistently
3 - Usually
4 - Consistently
5 - Usually

Musical Understanding
1 - Consistently
2 - Consistently
3 - Usually
4 - Consistently
5 - Usually

Rating = 2

This shouldn't be a thing.

https://www.uiltexas.org/files/music/Band_Concert_Evaluation_Rubric.pdf