Circe
PRIVATELY whispers to Herzog: I don't think the rules require the two parts of the post be separated with spaces. When you have 10 mins a spar you have time for that kind of stuff. The rules specifically state that when starting combat with a thrown weapon the reaction is repositioning the weapon to throw, and the counter is throwing. Since I did those things in that order, my throw fits prodigy rules. The other issue is, was my intent clear or confused? A nitpicker might say I was not clear on how I threw the spear, but while there are many ways to throw a knife, there is only way to throw a spear. Prodigy says it is supposed to be simple, and overcomplicating simple actions is not really the intent of the system. Finally, nobody can ever be as wrong as you think everybody who disagrees with you is wrong. There are other things between your opinion, and complete idiot. That is what prevents effective communication.
(05:08:07 ) Herzog PRIVATELY whispers to ____Panthera sincerus___: You are wrong on pretty much everything you have just posted. The only time you are allowed a one part post is during a counterattack. All other times a prodigy post consists of two parts. Just because you don't have to defend an attack doesn't mean that you don't need BOTH parts of those posts. There is a reason why every single spar that is on the IC boards have posts with two sections to them. I don't think everyone who disagrees with me is wrong. I know for a fact that you are. That is not my opinion, that is the way the rules are written. It is a fact.
(05:09:02 ) ____Panthera sincerus____Arn and Grenna's Band, Northern Forest IC
[PIC]
Circe
PRIVATELY whispers to Herzog: Where does it say the two parts have to be separated, as opposed to simply being in the right order?
(05:10:43 ) ____Panthera sincerus____Arn and Grenna's Band, Northern Forest IC
[PIC]
Circe
PRIVATELY whispers to Herzog: When you are 1-1 in a spar, you have time to make it easy for the judge. But in OC in a crowded room, the judge has to be the one to figure out what everybody intended. What would you say, since my spear throw did not meet your minimum standards, it never happened?
(05:10:57 ) Herzog PRIVATELY whispers to ____Panthera sincerus___: -laughs- seriously? I'm not here to teach you prodigy. You're on your own with that.
(05:11:56 ) Herzog PRIVATELY whispers to ____Panthera sincerus___: that is the point with open combat. I have killed 2 people in 2 on 1 open combat, and managed to make concise and clear posts with no problem whatsoever. I would say that your spear throw never happened, unless you and your opponent agreed on some other fighting style
(05:13:11 ) ____Panthera sincerus____Arn and Grenna's Band, Northern Forest IC
[PIC]
Circe
PRIVATELY whispers to Herzog: If a fighter intends to begin his battle and has the opening counter post with the intent to use a missile weapon, such as a spear or quiva or throwing knife, he may use the opening counter only to adjust his body or begin to get a running start. The actual throwing of the weapon is to be performed in the reaction phase of the post, and will be considered as that rounds attack.
My spear throw had both those elements, cocking the spear to throw, and throwing. Reaction and counter, just like in the rule.
(05:14:23 ) ____Panthera sincerus____Arn and Grenna's Band, Northern Forest IC
[PIC]
Circe
PRIVATELY whispers to Herzog: You squirm when you are proved wrong. Where does it say that the reaction and counter have to be separated? It doesn't. The spaces btw are simply a convention that started to simplify judging, and is not a required element.
(05:15:40 ) Herzog PRIVATELY whispers to ____Panthera sincerus___: it A. wasn't broken into 2 parts, and B. after your spear throw you had drawing of a quiva, which was a second, non-fluid, non-flowing action.
(05:15:46 ) ____Panthera sincerus____Arn and Grenna's Band, Northern Forest IC
[PIC]
Circe
PRIVATELY whispers to Herzog: There were 6 people involved in that RP that I had to read their posts, there was no time to be pretty like the 12 min spars you fight in that league.
(05:16:25 ) Herzog PRIVATELY whispers to ____Panthera sincerus___: why is it that I can do it in 8 minutes and you can't?
The smell of rain is in the air,and now the first drops felt as light touches of mist upon Your skin
(05:16:33 ) ____Panthera sincerus____Arn and Grenna's Band, Northern Forest IC
[PIC]
Circe
PRIVATELY whispers to Herzog: The quiva draw might well be illegal, but that is a separate issue.
(05:17:42 ) ____Panthera sincerus____Arn and Grenna's Band, Northern Forest IC
[PIC]
Circe
PRIVATELY whispers to Herzog: Again, you are squirming. Show me the rule that says it has to "broken". The rules simply describe two necessary elements, both of which were met by my spear throw, as Trei judged. So you must be wrong, huh?
(05:18:01 ) Herzog PRIVATELY whispers to ____Panthera sincerus___: so, your post that looked and was set up like an AlterRealm OC post, with 3 actions, unbroken, is somehow just a poorly constructed Prodigy post. I got it.
(05:20:48 ) Herzog PRIVATELY whispers to ____Panthera sincerus___: if you are right, don't break your posts, get your fights judged, and good luck. -laughs-
(05:22:45 ) ____Panthera sincerus____Arn and Grenna's Band, Northern Forest IC
[PIC]
Circe
PRIVATELY whispers to Herzog: I hadn't seen that exact rule about the setup to throw being the reaction, so I thought cocking and throwing was one smooth action, and rearming a legal counter. Now I see otherwise. I didn't have the quiva in hand, which was never used anyway. Seems like a minor quibble over a mistake I won't make next time. I'll have the quiva in hand during the weapon post.
(05:23:21 ) ____Panthera sincerus____Arn and Grenna's Band, Northern Forest IC
[PIC]
Circe
PRIVATELY whispers to Herzog: You simply do not have to break the posts in OC, as Trei clearly judged.
(05:24:48 ) Herzog PRIVATELY whispers to ____Panthera sincerus___: Oh, I didn't know Trei was the most knowledgeable prodigy judge! I thought it was Cyruss who wrote it and with whom I am speaking with right now about it.
(05:25:17 ) ____Panthera sincerus____Arn and Grenna's Band, Northern Forest IC
[PIC]
Circe
PRIVATELY whispers to Herzog: See, I am right, I didn't break my post, got it judged, as a valid post. So you are wrong. You are whining about a judgment you disagree with.
(05:26:39 ) Herzog PRIVATELY whispers to ____Panthera sincerus___: I must have been doing it wrong all this time. And all the judges who are judging me must have been pretty bad to keep giving me clean posts. Listen, you are wrong. You are self-absorbed and think you are the end all be all fighter of the forest. Honestly? most of the panther girls would wipe the floor with you in open combat, even as rank amateurs. Good luck with learning, and hopefully you cease being so pompous and actually take some advice of someone who knows more than you to heart.
Spring is here, warm fingers of sun melting the snow underfoot as the thaw takes hold
(05:26:51 ) ____Panthera sincerus____Arn and Grenna's Band, Northern Forest IC
[PIC]
Circe
PRIVATELY whispers to Herzog: Cyruss is corrupt, lying scumbag. Interesting how you forgive his past, and hate me so much for mine.
(05:27:39 ) ____Panthera sincerus____Arn and Grenna's Band, Northern Forest IC
[PIC]
Circe
PRIVATELY whispers to Herzog: You want to bet something on that?
(05:28:12 ) Anonymous : Enters...
(05:29:24 ) Herzog PRIVATELY whispers to ____Panthera sincerus___: no, Cyruss WROTE prodigy. His past means nothing in regards to the fighting style. And I could give a #### less about your past too when it comes to Prodigy. You are doing it wrong, good luck figuring it out. Hopefully it is before some other Panther girl enslaves you.
(05:30:30 ) ____Panthera sincerus____Arn and Grenna's Band, Northern Forest IC
[PIC]
Circe
PRIVATELY whispers to Herzog: Let's bet on that. I'll bet you can't find another Panther who will even fight me.
(05:32:06 ) Herzog PRIVATELY whispers to ____Panthera sincerus___: like I said. -smiles- best of luck to you.
(05:32:53 ) ____Panthera sincerus____Arn and Grenna's Band, Northern Forest IC
[PIC]
Circe
PRIVATELY whispers to Herzog: Put up or shut up. Quote me where the rule says the two parts of the post have to be separated. Or find a Panther who will fight me, and wager on it. Or, maybe even lose to me yourself? With your male strength advantage, and better weapon advantage, you probably could beat me. But with equal weapons, I'd wipe the floor with your corpse.
(05:35:09 ) Herzog PRIVATELY whispers to ____Panthera sincerus___: ahahahahahahahaha now I know you are just trolling and coming here was a waste of my time. I could fight you spear to spear and you'd be at my feet in the first post. Seriously. good luck to you. I wish you the best in your endeavors to learn prodigy
(05:36:31 ) ____Panthera sincerus____Arn and Grenna's Band, Northern Forest IC
[PIC]
Circe
PRIVATELY whispers to Herzog: That is neither putting up nor shutting up. Quote, wager, fight. O for 3 on your part. But I appreciate you trying to reach out. Maybe next time we will find something to agree upon.
(05:38:03 ) ____Panthera sincerus____Arn and Grenna's Band, Northern Forest IC
[PIC]
Circe
PRIVATELY whispers to Herzog: That sounds like an interesting wager. One round. You kill me, or I win. Your words, put up or shut up.
(05:39:19 ) Herzog PRIVATELY whispers to ____Panthera sincerus___: -laughs- I wouldn't lower myself to fight you, first of all. It is poor form to embarrass a rank amateur publically. You can find your quotes in any one of the judgements that you have been browsing on the board. -laughs- like I said, have a nice day, Circe. and good luck. You'll need it
(05:39:30 ) ____Panthera sincerus____Arn and Grenna's Band, Northern Forest IC
[PIC]
Circe
PRIVATELY whispers to Herzog: Your words: I could fight you spear to spear and you'd be at my feet in the first post. There you go. One round. You kill me I'm dead. You don't kill me, you're dead.
(05:39:58 ) Anonymous : Enters...
(05:40:04 ) ____Panthera sincerus____Arn and Grenna's Band, Northern Forest IC
[PIC]
Circe
PRIVATELY whispers to Herzog: Yeah, yeah. That's what cowards always say. You're too good to fight me.
Message Thread | This response ↓
« Back to index
Responses are not allowed!
Create your own free message board!