I didn't, but it wasn't me drawing conclusions without that knowledge. As I've already said to you, I've asked railwayender (and others) many, many times to expand on their opinions and have unsurprisingly been met with radio silence.
You might think 'shutting them down' isn't beneficial to anyone, but making baseless statements about people at the club is also not beneficial.
I've said it many times on here, if you're going to put an opinion on a public messageboard then don't be surprised when someone has an opinion in response.