I was commenting purely on the fact that you've got no idea what he bases his opinions on. The name change for a job we're all familiar with has obviously thrown us all. I don't think you knew what being head of emerging talent meant until I told you did you?
Anyway, us laymen messageboard inhabitants talking sh*te are what makes this place interesting. Allowing someone to get something off their chest once in a while could be therapeutic for both the writer and the reader. Immediately shutting them down like Viz's Mr. Logic isn't beneficial to anyone.
I base that opinion on my experiences on various messageboards over the last 14 years.