Bearing in mind the disgraceful way Francisco Saverio (Francois Xavier) behaved, his family can have no claim on anything.
Duke Roberto I had intended that the bulk of his inheritance should pass to the line descended from his first marriage, but he insured that all the children of his 2nd marriage were well looked after. His two older sons who were mentally incompetent, were in the care of their brother Elias - as they were Austrian citizens when WWI broke out, the French government confiscated all their property in France (just as Austria and Germany confiscated the property of all French citizens in those countries). This is a normal act in war. However, Francois Xavier and his brother Sixte (but led by the former) tried to claim that they were French citizens and therefore under French law that they should inherit the chateau and estate of Chambord, which had passed by inheritance from the Comte de Chambord to his nephew the Duke of Parma, Roberto I. So these two brothers instituted a law case against their older half-brothers to try and get possession of Chambord. They eventually lost the case as the French courts decided they were actually not French but Spanish. But this cost a great deal of money and destroyed the family relationship. Then, when the Austrian-French treaty was signed which settled property issues, the French government, which had been watching this case, demanded a clause be inserted that gave the government the right to pre-emptively acquire any Austrian owned property - this was of course aimed at Chambord, which Prince (and future Duke) Elias was forced to hand over to the French government for a fraction of its value.
Years later when Archduke Otto came to Madrid to receive the Order of San Gennaro from Infante Don Carlos on the occasion of his 90th birthday, this unhappy episode was discussed and Otto apologised as his mother had assigned her claim (which was in any case rejected) to her brothers, but had never participated in the court case.
F-X in 1931 acknowledged Alfonso XIII as future head of the dynasty and the Royal House of France at the funeral in Paris of the Duke of Madrid. But he then found it advantageous to sign up to Carlism and the last Carlist claimant, the elderly Duke of San Jaime, appointed him "regent of the Carlist tradition," whatever that meant. When the latter died, in 1936, he ordered that the collars of the Saint Esprit which had been bequeathed to the Duke of Madrid, his older brother, by the Count of Chambord (as Chambord, titular Henri V, considered the Duke of Madrid his eventual heir as head of the royal house of France), be given to King Alfonso XIII - which the previous head of the dynasty, Jaime, Duke of Madrid, had indicated he wished in 1931 when he had bestowed the Saint Esprit on the King (the diploma described him as "Prince Alfonso"). The Duke of San Jaime had given this responsibility to his secretary but the latter was a Carlist, and strong opponent of the constitutional monarchy and therefore of Alfonso XIII. So instead of giving them to the King, he handed them over to F-X de BP who had no claim on these collars whatsoever. Nonetheless he kept them, at Lignieres, and they are now in the possession of his son Sixte-Henri, who likewise has no ownership rights at all. That has not stopped him selling two, pawning another (which was then sold by the pawnbroker at auction) and recently trying to sell another along with his mother's tiara, at Sotheby's Geneva. Another family member intervened and the sale of these was stopped at the last minute.
The collars belong to the person who is head of the royal house of France as heir of the kings of France (a position that is disputed today). The last undisputed claimant, Henri Count of Chambord considered that person to be the Duke of Madrid, which is why they were bequeathed to him. The descendants of F-X have no right to any of this.
« Back to index