Basically, Dosser believes that to get promotion you should follow the Dave Jones philosophy of recruiting from divisions above you. Jones, Bennett, Marsden, Angell, etc. So we should be getting a league keeper to replace Hinchliffe.
JG is more from the school of find players who can play at the level you are in but can be coached to play at a higher level, which he proved on the 2 occasions he led us to promotion.
Who is correct is a matter of conjecture. In reality a combination of both is probably ideal. After all, recruiting a number of players who had played at higher levels didn’t work out so well for Neil Young or Jimmy Melia.