Croasdale was very good for 3-4 months but absolutely bobbins last 5-6 weeks of the season, not convinced he has the mobility or range of passing, he's in the will do for now category for me
Collar I just don't see anything in at all to suggest we should have give him a 2yr deal, no better than Keane, backup at best for me, very ineffectual in a lot of games including the Hartlepool one
Whitfield I haven't seen yet but comes highly rated but has had injuries, so reserve judgement til I see more of him
Newby for me will have his good games, but its countered by a lack of consistent end product and for the money we paid for him I think we could have put that to good use to get someone better who was out of contract at a league club, he was decent value for us on loan and gave us different option
But how many goals did he score (0) and not many telling contributions in terms of creating goals for us, a bit of an enigma will look a world beater on his day when everything comes off, but too many games where for all he looks bright he doesn't provide that killer pass or finish