I can name players for City and United because everyone round here goes on about them. Could have a good go at Liverpool’s squad and a fair chunk of Chelsea and Tottenham, but would really struggle elsewhere with the likes of Watford (Deeney......), Burnley (Dwight McNeil because of his dad), Brighton (Glenn Murray, ..... erm after that.... no idea), Villa (Grealish......). Arsenal ......Ozil and Augbayemang...after that - nope.
20 years ago I could have named the bulk of all the first teams.