AC made 1 out, but how many runs did he give up with those defensive skills

ap had a bad day. Tom Brady has interceptions, Mike Tyson got knocked out, Greg Maddux walked some batters, shit happens, people have a bad day and Andy is 50+ still playing at a level you'll never get to

Ap didn't always have the best defenses, he didn't just fall out of the sky and land on major teams. You think maybe has had some of the best talent around because he's also one of the most talented? See how that works. Typically the best of the best play on the same team.
You might want to go back and watch some of the previous years MWS when Andy single handily shut down innings.

He played on those levels and apparently was a little above average.