The easiest way to handle awards, player classifications, team classifications etc. etc. is to be transparent.
Awards, for example:
1. How many awards will be given?
2. How many per position?
3. Who nominates them and what is that process?
4. Whos selects the award winners? and how?
5. Is there a QA process (so as to effectively evaluate the process)?
Basically - someone has to own the processes and care about improving the existing structure.