Flack29 is probably right on the mark with what he deduced. I have a sneaking suspicion runner would have been out if game was a little closer. To be honest my daughter plays on a "not so good" high school team and I've seen umps do that over the last few years. In fact my son goes to the same high school and have seen it happen to his baseball team over the past 3 seasons too!!! Yep. Now I'm convinced. In the end the scoresheet only means something if one or the other team has to use it to get into the playoffs. I'll assume this late in the season with the game you were scoring they are in the playoffs so season over?