I am in a similar place. I want to point at the rubric and judge comments and ask for a specific breakdown on each item, possibly on a five point scale. I would like to see the receipts of their opinion, laid out numerically and calculated against a range to determine the rating. I would like to see that for each piece so that it is incredibly clear where the problems exist. I would prefer this over written comments. This is probably a huge ask to our judges and colleagues, but I do not feel that it is transparent enough. Near impossible to accomplish, but man would it would put to bed some lingering feelings and thoughts.
|