[Return to the Ms. Marvel Message Board] [Post A Reply]

so definitive in the absence of verification?? :P

Posted by Cascadyan on 6/2/2009, 1:06 am, in reply to "And you would be WRONG :P"
203.39.81.94

: in truth, this is just speculation on my : part.. but as soon as Carol 'died' I knew : (well, felt it was prudent to) I needed to : be on the lookout for any 'mysterious energy : creatures' popping up... as they could be : Carol trying to pull herself back : together... : There is NO WAY that is Carol or even Carol : related. For one; the energy women (I think : there is more than one, due to the different : colours) are killing people. Lots of : people. That isn't/wasn't Carol's style. : And two; it's too soon to bring Carol back. : Brian Reed can easily milk 12 issues out of : Karla before Carol gets the book back. And : personally I hope she never does. Karla's : too wonderful to be replaced; Carol is : better on a team. Kieran - your ability to be so darn DEFINITIVE in the absence of verifiable evidence / fact... to a post that indicated it was purely SPECUALTION comes across as petulence / arrogance of a very high order... if thats what you were going for - you succeeded.. to put it succinctly... there is no way you can say 'No Way'... to a plot point that is yet to be resolved. there is NO EVIDENCE that this energy woman (who can change colours) OR Women - cos it could concievably be multiple versions of the one being given the... you guessed it - lack of verifiable evidence to the contrary.. (my money is on Carol, regardless of the 'colour' issue) that this woman is NOT Carol... we are speculating... Oh, thats right, Carol has never killed..! She never killed (specifically let DIE when could have prevented/saved) the Puppet Master in the early 20's issues... She NEVER slaughtered untold numbers of skrulls during SI... she has never shown a tendancy of being a tad brash - shoot first, asked questions later (Arachne)... thats right, Miss Carol is a lil goody-two-shoes butter would not melt in her mouth type... NOT where does it say that its 'too soon' to bring carol back? What are you basing that on?? History, instinct, hot air or the previews?? Surely not the preview covers for the 40's that have shown a 'Carol-Ms Marvel-look-alike'. History is no reliable judge (in any definitive way) - cos then that becomes predictable'... your instinct is neither better OR worse than anyone elses (btw - I 'called it' successfully on karla becoming a major part of this book loooong before any initial announcement, on this VERY board)... that leaves HOT AIR *pfffft* Just because Reed can milk 12 issues, doesnt mean he will - I suspect it will tie up along with the rest of Dark Reign (D'oh).. and certainly in no way precludes Carol from being a main character in the book... And REED has categorically stated that Carol WILL be back (my bet is issue 50).. so your hopes & wishes about karla seem to be destined to remain as insubstantial as your other errm 'comments' Even your comment about 'Carol is better on a team' is redundant given she has had her own team IN her Solo Book, whilst also leading Mighty avengers (and now appreaing in NA)... so that one has been contradicted by previous issues of this book.. which I wonder if you have read.. so, before making definitive statements about the level of 'wrong-ness' in someones speculation.. ya may in future just like to check yourself first - LOL! Happy Ms Marvel-ing

---

Message Thread I'm Calling it... Ms Marvel 39 preview SPOILERS - Cascadyan 5/27/2009, 10:31 am Re: I'm Calling it... Ms Marvel 39 preview SPOILERS - jediwalkerofsky 7/16/2009, 3:57 pm Re: Ms Marvel 39 preview SPOILERS - emerick-man 5/31/2009, 3:18 pm I think.... [spoilers] - Kieran Frost 5/31/2009, 4:02 pm Re: I think.... [spoilers] - Attok12 6/1/2009, 10:13 am Re: I think.... [spoilers] - Kieran Frost 6/2/2009, 2:21 pm And you would be WRONG :P - Kieran Frost 5/31/2009, 11:23 am so definitive in the absence of verification?? :P - Cascadyan 6/2/2009, 1:06 am "Miss Carol is a lil goody-two-shoes butter would not melt in her mouth type... LOL!" i'm amused! nm - DGTrixie 6/2/2009, 2:44 pm Woah, woah, woah... danger, Will Robinson - Kieran Frost 6/2/2009, 2:15 pm And I Think It May Be... - Attok12 5/28/2009, 9:09 am Please let the Pink Lady be Carol... PLEASE! PLEASE! PLEASE! nm - DGTrixie 5/27/2009, 9:11 pm Re: I'm Calling it... Ms Marvel 39 preview SPOILERS - BernieB 5/27/2009, 9:06 pm « Back to index

---

Post a Response