Re: Judging vs BSU
Posted by RM! on 2/26/2012, 12:18 pm, in reply to "Re: Judging vs BSU"
My notes for Makayla on beam - two checks - all else beauty! 9.65 with a 9.9 start from one judge.
9.725 seemed like a fair score to me. Her bars set was absolutely awesome and that's where I thought we would have seen a higher score.
It also is common that the same routine in position one would get a lower score if it were performed in slot six. Shouldn't be that way but it's typical
: I'm an "experienced" watcher, but
: not a great judge... but Makayla had 9.900
: start value on beam, and I think that was
: due to a missed connection (at least as the
: judges saw it)... I'd have to watch it again
: to possibly have an idea what other
: deductions they might have taken.
: Sorry to say, I tend to not watch the other
: team any where near as closely as OSU, to be
: able to form an opinion about their scores,
: but it did seem some of the floor scores
: were a little high.
: I know there are many things I miss seeing
: watching live, that could be deductions,
: some because I don't know they are
: deductions or because my eyes aren't trained
: well enough. Some deductions are a fixed
: value, others are within a range. Just in my
: viewing ability, it many times happens that
: I don't agree with the low (or high) judge's
: score, but the average seems about right
: (maybe within 0.025).